There’s a particular kind of comfort that comes from seeing money in the bank. Not “new-car” comfort. Not “holiday” comfort. The deeper kind: I can breathe. I can handle it if something goes wrong. My kids will be okay.
For single mum Jackie*, that feeling matters. Jackie lives in New South Wales. She has two children. She works part-time to fit around school hours. After a divorce, Jackie received a $500,000 settlement, which has become her main financial safety net.
Jackie wants to buy a home for her and the kids, but prices in her area are too high for one income, and she cannot borrow much. She finds herself dipping into the settlement money each month to help cover day-to-day living costs alongside wages and family benefits, but wants to stop this.
So what should Jackie do?
Does she buy something now, where she can afford, so she’s “in the market”? Or does she keep the cash, try to earn more, and buy later where she really wants to live?
This choice is not just maths. It is emotional too.
Let’s look at the options.
First, a truth about “security”
Jackie’s $500,000 feels safe because it is easy to see and easy to access the money in the bank. But right now, it is doing two jobs at once.
One: a safety buffer for emergencies. Two: extra money to cover the bills.
The second job is the risky one.
If Jackie keeps dipping into her savings each month, they can drop faster than she expects. That quietly reduces the deposit she has available later. And if the money just sits in cash, rising prices and inflation can make it harder to catch up over time.
So the real question is this: how can Jackie stay safe right now, stop her savings from slowly shrinking, and still move closer to owning a home?
Option 1: Buy a cheaper property now as an investment
Because Jackie cannot borrow much, she could buy a small property in a more affordable area using cash outright. No mortgage. No bank approval needed.
Why this can help
She gets into the property market sooner. Some of her cash becomes an asset that may grow in value over time. Rental income can help with weekly costs.
What to watch out for
Being a landlord still costs money. Rates, insurance, repairs, and property management fees all add up. If Jackie spends most of her cash on the purchase, her safety buffer could become dangerously thin, if she doesn’t find a way to also boost her income. It also doesn’t solve her main goal, which is to find a home for her and her children where she wants to live.
When this option makes sense
This can work if Jackie can keep a strong emergency buffer after buying, increases her income, chooses a property in a genuinely good location rather than just a cheap one, and treats it as a stepping stone rather than the end goal.
Option 2: Keep the cash, build income, and buy what she actually wants later
The other path is to leave the settlement money where it is for now, stop using it for everyday costs, and focus on earning more. More hours, a better-paid role, a career change, a second income stream over time.
Why this can work
A higher income changes a lot. It increases how much Jackie can borrow, which opens up her up to more property options. It also means she stops chipping away at the safety net every month, so the $500,000 actually stays $500,000.
What to watch out for
Waiting is hard when you’re renting with kids and watching prices go up. And there’s no guarantee things will get easier. Prices can rise while Jackie works on her income, and that gap can feel massive.
When this option makes sense
If buying now would leave Jackie with too little buffer, if what she can actually afford right now is not somewhere she’d feel good about raising her kids, or if a rushed decision would create more pressure than it relieves, then waiting with a real plan is the stronger choice.
Option 3: The middle path – building a staged plan
Most people frame this as a binary. Buy now or wait. But, there’s a middle path. Jackie can build a staged plan. Not a rushed decision in either direction, but a clear sequence of small moves that protects her security today, while building toward ownership over time.
That might start with getting clear on what the settlement money is actually for. What amount stays untouched no matter what. What’s the buffer that means Jackie and her kids are okay if something unexpected happens. And what’s above that line that could be working harder.
Then, close the monthly shortfall. If savings are being used every month, that’s the thing to fix first. Not dramatically, just steadily. Review what’s going out, check whether she’s accessing the benefits shes entitled to, and make a realistic plan to increase income over 6-12 months. Even a small shift here can she things meaningfully.
Once those pieces are in place, the decision to buy becomes a lot cleare. Maybe it’s the investment property. Maybe it’s waiting for a better home. Maybe it’s rentvesting, which means renting where she wants to live while buying where she can afford. Maybe it’s none of these. That decision is much easier to make from a position of stability than anxiety and stress.
If you’re sitting with a similar question, these are worth thinking about
- If I bought something tomorrow, what would my cash buffer look like the day after? If that number feels tight, it’s worth noticing that feeling. Tight is not security. Tight is just a different kind of stress.
- How long would my savings actually last if things stayed the same? Doing that maths, properly, is almost always less frightening than not knowing.
- Am I thinking about buying because it’s the right move right now, or because I need to feel like I’m doing something? Both are human. Only one of them is a good reason to make a major financial decision.
- What does my income look like in 12 to 24 months if I actually focus on it? Even a modest increase can change the borrowing picture significantly.
Jackie’s story is a case study for illustrative purposes only. This article is general information and is not financial advice, tax advice or legal advice. Every person’s situation is different. Please speak with a licensed professional before making any decisions about property or savings.
If you’re looking for guidance on your home ownership journey, sign up to Penny at urpenny.com.